top of page

Debunking Common Dog Training Myths & Why Positive Training is the BEST choice for all dogs!

Writer: Theodora Iancu
Theodora Iancu
Nov 6
5 min read

If you think dog training means yelling or using harsh tools to get compliance, it’s time for a reality check! Positive training is not just a fluffy trend, it’s the smartest, kindest, and most effective way to teach your dog. Yet, plenty of dog lovers still fall for dog training myths that paint positive methods as "weak" or "ineffective". Well I'm here to help set the record straight!


How I Learned the Hard Way: My Personal Dog Training Journey


Here's Max before I discovered positive dog training. Sadly, he was often very anxious :'(
Here's Max before I discovered positive dog training. Sadly, he was often very anxious :'(

When my family first got our first dogs, two dachshunds named Brownie and Copper, I thought training was all about discipline and control. I tried the old-school methods: stern commands, leash jerks, and even some “tough love” advice from well-meaning friends. Spoiler alert: Our dogs became confused, scared, and downright distrusting.


Regular walks were a tug-of-war, and I was always wondering how others got their dogs to walk nicely...and unfortunately that's how their entire lives were lived. Everyday I wish I could've given them better lives even though I only did what I knew at the time, also I was only a teen at the time. I was ignorant to the science behind dog training back then. They were "spoiled" dogs nonetheless, other than the obvious distrust and occasional fear...


After switching to positive methods,and a comfy harness, Max started coming back to me whenever I called LIKE THIS! Doesn't he just look HAPPIER?
After switching to positive methods,and a comfy harness, Max started coming back to me whenever I called LIKE THIS! Doesn't he just look HAPPIER?

Then I stumbled upon positive training. At first, I was skeptical. Could giving treats and praise really replace teaching "discipline"? I gave it a shot with our third family dog, a "chiweenie" chihuahua dachshund mix named Max, and the change was instant and almost magical! I used to use old school methods with him as well. You can see him in the first pic wearing a choke chain with an anxious look on his face.


But when I switched over to positive methods ONLY Max started responding eagerly, his tail wagging, and our bond grew stronger. No yelling, no fear, just clear communication and rewards! That experience taught me one thing: positive training works because it respects your dog’s feelings and intelligence. It’s not about domination; it’s about partnership.



What Positive Training Really Means


Positive training focuses on rewarding good behavior rather than punishing bad behavior. It uses treats, toys, praise, and affection to motivate dogs. This approach builds trust and encourages dogs to repeat behaviors that earn rewards.


Here’s what positive training is not:


  • It’s not bribery. Rewards are given for desired behaviors, not just to keep your dog quiet.

  • It’s not permissive. You still set boundaries and rules.

  • It’s not a quick fix. It requires patience and consistency.


Positive training creates a happy dog who wants to learn and please you because they enjoy the process!



Common Dog Training Myths and Why They’re Wrong


Let’s bust some of the biggest dog training myths that keep people stuck in outdated methods.


Myth 1: Positive Training Is Too Soft and Dogs Won’t Respect You


This myth assumes dogs only respond to fear or force. In reality, respect comes from clear communication and trust. Dogs trained positively are confident and eager to follow cues because they understand what you want and feel safe doing it.


I intentionally use the word “cues” instead of “commands” because we're communicating with our dogs, not ordering them around like a drill sergeant! The word “commands” implies obedience and compliance rather than cooperation and understanding. It can also make us more frustrated if our dogs don't respond, because we start thinking they're disobeying us instead of asking ourselves why they're having trouble responding to the cue.


Myth 2: You Can’t Fix Serious Behavior Problems with Positive Training


Many believe that aggressive or "stubborn" dogs need harsh corrections. Research and countless trainers prove otherwise. Positive training addresses root causes like fear, excitement, and anxiety, replacing negative reactions with calm, controlled responses. For example, counter-conditioning and desensitization techniques help aggressive dogs become more relaxed around triggers.


Myth 3: Positive Training Takes Too Long


Yes, positive training requires patience, but it’s more effective long-term. Harsh methods might get quick compliance but often cause stress, confusion, and relapse. Positive training builds lasting habits and a strong bond, saving time and frustration down the road as well as a ton of unnecessary stress for your dog!


Myth 4: Treats Spoil Dogs and Make Them Dependent


Treats are tools, not bribes. When used correctly, they motivate learning and reinforce good behavior. Over time, you can reduce treats and replace them with praise or play. Dogs don’t become spoiled; they become motivated learners!


Myth 5: Using Treats to Train your Dog will Make Them Overweight


Positive reinforcement training doesn't automatically cause weight gain. Consistently consuming more calories than your dog needs does! Think about it, you don't have to give your dog an entire biscuit every time they do something you want to reinforce. Dogs can easily be motivated by rewards they love even in tiny amounts!


Here's how you can use food rewards responsibly:

  • Use tiny treats! Sometimes a little pea-sized reward is all you need.

  • Use their regular meals! Set aside a portion of their daily kibble for training instead of adding extra food.

  • Be mindful of calories! Treats and other extras should generally make up no more than 10% of your dog's daily caloric intake.

  • Use other rewards, too! Sniffing, playing, praise, and access to favorite activities can all be rewarding, depending on what your individual dog enjoys.

  • Save the really good stuff! Higher-value treats can be especially useful during difficult training situations.


And remember, positive reinforcement isn't about stuffing your dog with treats until they listen! It's about identifying what your dog finds rewarding and using it thoughtfully to reinforce behaviors we'd like to see more often.


The problem isn't positive reinforcement. It's failing to account for your dog's nutritional needs!

You can absolutely train your dog using compassionate, science-based methods while helping them maintain a healthy weight.



Why Positive Training Works Better for Dogs and Humans


Positive training taps into how dogs naturally learn. Dogs are social animals who thrive on rewards and clear signals. Here’s why it works:


  • Builds trust: Dogs feel safe and willing to cooperate.

  • Strengthens bonds: Training becomes fun for both dog and owner.

  • Reduces stress: No fear or pain means happier dogs.

  • Improves learning: Positive reinforcement encourages repetition.

  • Fits all dogs: Works for puppies, adults, shy dogs, and even reactive dogs.



Practical Tips for Positive Dog Training Success


Ready to ditch the myths and embrace positive training? Here are some tips to get started:


  • Use high-value treats your dog loves.

  • Keep training sessions short and fun.

  • Reward immediately after the desired behavior.

  • Be consistent with your cues and signals.

  • Ignore minor misbehaviors instead of punishing.

  • Use a clicker or marker word to signal correct behavior.

  • Gradually increase distractions to build reliability.

  • Celebrate small wins and be patient.



What to Avoid When Starting Positive Training


Even the best intentions can backfire if you:


  • Use punishment alongside rewards (confuses dogs).

  • Expect instant results.

  • Forget to reward every good behavior.

  • Use rewards your dog doesn’t care about.

  • Train when you or your dog are tired or distracted.


Stick to clear, consistent, and kind methods for the best results.



How to Handle Critics of Positive Training


You’ll meet skeptics who say positive training is “too soft” or “not real training.”

Here’s how to respond:


  • Share your success stories and your dog’s happy behavior.

  • Explain how positive training builds trust and long-term results.

  • Point out that harsh methods can cause fear and aggression.

  • Invite them to watch a positive training session.


Most people come around when they see the proof! Never let them change your mind no matter what legit-sounding yet totally unsupported "scientific" reasons they may come up with! By choosing the Fear Free route, you're choosing safety, clarity, and overall happiness for your dog to live the best quality of life!


 
 
 

Comments


Theo's Doggos

Thoughtful Guidance, Lasting Change

Theo's Doggos Dog Heart Silhouette Logo
Paw Prints Logo
Victoria Stilwell Academy Certified Badge

Follow me on Facebook, Youtube, and Instagram for 

cute pictures and videos I took, informative articles, tips, and more.

Click on any logo to learn more!​

  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Instagram Social Icon
VSA Reactivity Zone Approach for Reactive Dogs
Fear Free Certified Professional Badge
Fear Free Logo
bottom of page